What’s the right balance between premium cost and out-of-pocket exposure (deductibles, coinsurance)?

The right balance makes healthcare both affordable and usable. Premiums should stay competitive, but deductibles and out-of-pocket costs must be low enough that employees actually use their benefits. The goal is to manage total cost, not just premiums, while protecting access to everyday care.

‍

Focus on total cost of care, not just premiums
Lower premiums can backfire if high deductibles or coinsurance discourage care. Delayed treatment often leads to higher claims later.

• Premiums: Predictable, shared costs for employers and employees.
• Out-of-pocket costs: Unpredictable expenses that can deter employees from seeking care.

Best practice: Keep the services employees use most — primary care, mental health, and prescriptions — free or low-cost, even if that means slightly higher premiums.

Keep everyday care free or predictable
Affordable access encourages engagement.

• Make primary and preventive care $0, with no deductible or copay.
• Keep generic prescriptions and mental health visits low-cost or included.
• Use flat copays instead of coinsurance for simpler, more predictable costs.

Impact: Regular engagement reduces emergency room visits and hospitalizations, balancing total spend.

Adjust deductibles strategically, not uniformly
High-deductible plans can lower premiums but shift more cost to employees. Instead:

• Offer a moderate-deductible core plan with strong primary care access.
• Provide a buy-up option for employees who want richer coverage.
• Pair HDHPs with $0 primary care (such as Vitable) so employees can still access care before meeting the deductible. 

Result: Employees have clear choices and consistent care access without sudden cost spikes.

Replace coinsurance with transparent pricing
Coinsurance percentages can create uncertainty. Use flat-dollar copays or bundled pricing for high-value services instead.

Impact: Simplifies decision-making, builds trust, and improves plan utilization.

Evaluate affordability for all income levels
A plan that works for higher earners may not be affordable for hourly or lower-income workers.

• Keep employee-only premiums within ACA affordability limits (8.39 percent of household income for 2024).
• Consider tiered contributions or plan options based on income groups.

Always protect $0 access to preventive and primary care for true equity.

Vitable helps employers balance premiums and out-of-pocket costs by removing financial barriers to everyday care. Every plan includes $0 primary care, mental health, and prescription access, available virtually or in-home. This lets employers adjust deductibles or copays elsewhere without compromising quality or access.

‍

A sustainable plan keeps premiums manageable while ensuring employees can afford and use their benefits.

• Make primary, mental health, and preventive care $0.
• Use simple cost-sharing for less frequent services.
• Rely on Vitable’s primary-care-first model to bridge the gap between cost control and care quality.

‍